Showing posts with label Thacher. Show all posts
Showing posts with label Thacher. Show all posts

Wednesday, January 9, 2013

New Dimensions in Slide Rule Technology

The other day I posted that there is a new record that has been set with the development of the Eximius Diu 6 slide rule by David Hoyer. Please see my post on this subject.

In thinking about this slide rule I realized that it is a member of a class of slide rules that doesn't get much attention.  Let me be more specific.
We are all familiar with the linear slide rule.  This is a slide rule like the K&E Deci-Lon. Here the scales are linear and can be moved relative to each other with the aid of a cursor to keep track of specific points on the scales and to transfer a reading from one scale to another.
Also, we are all familiar with the circular slide rule. This would be slide rules like the Gilson Midget Circular Slide rule. Here there are typically two indicators that you can set the distance between and then move them to another position on the slide rule without changing the angle between them.
Finally, there are the cylindrical slide rules Like the K&E 4012 Thacher slide rule.  Here, in effect, the scales are wound in a helical fashion around a cylinder.  This was done to get a longer scale in a smaller space, increasing accuracy. Interestingly, Professor Fuller and his cylindrical slide rule call his slide rule "spiral"

What David Hoyer has done with his Eximius Diu 6 slide rule design is to put a spiral scale on a flat surface, somewhat like a circular slide rule, but, unlike the circular slide rule, there is more than one revolution (or turn) that the scale transverses. This is very similar to the Ross Precision Computer, produced by Louis Ross in San Francisco in 1915. For more on the Ross Precision Computer see this post.  Another way of looking at this is that the circular slide rule is the degenerate case of the spiral slide rule where the scale only traverses one revolution.

The way to use the spiral slide rule is very similar to the circular slide rule with two indicators to mark the difference indicating an angle between two numbers.  But, unlike the circular slide rule where there is no ambiguity as to where the resultant number (solution of the multiplication or division) is located, this is not the case with the spiral slide rule.

Specifically, there are multiple possible results where the indicator crosses a scale and the user must select one.  The only way to determine which of these crossings is the correct one as suggested by Hoyer is to use a more conventional slide rule, either linear or circular, to approximate the solution, and then find the place where the indicator crosses the scale "near" the approximation. While some might say that this is begging the question of why to use the spiral slide rule, the answer, of course, is accuracy.  The Eximius Diu 6 pulls in a full 6 places of accuracy over its entire scale.

But, there is something unkosher about using this method to find the solution to an arithmetic computation on any slide rule. If you are going to use another device to get the solution, you may as well use an electronic calculator in the first place and get a precision of much greater than 6 places of accuracy.

So, the question I pose is whether there is some sort of mechanism in the way of arms, etc. that would allow the Eximius Diu 6 the throne for which it is intended?   Can we construct it in such a fashion that we do not have to go out to some auxiliary device to pull the answer out of the hat, so to speak?

Please comment below if you have a solution to this problem.

Wednesday, July 29, 2009

The Quest for the Holy Grail of Slide Rules

I will now tell an interesting story about something I uncovered.

In about 1997, I was sitting and working at my computer and an email popped into my mailbox.  Someone wanted to know if I wanted to buy a slide rule. I didn't recognize the name, but I answered anyway.  Okay I'll bite, "What kind of slide rule do you have? And, oh, by the way, where did you get my name or email address?"  Most slide rules that come up are fairly boring.

A little while later a reply came with more information. "It is a Thatcher and I saw your name on some website advertising that you want to buy slide rules."  "Interesting, a Thatcher." I thought. "I don't remember ever putting an ad anywhere for buying slide rules.  I wonder where she saw that"

There were two principal models of the Thatcher that were made. Production started in 1881. There is the 4012 model and the 4013 model.  Both are almost identical, except for one thing.  They both are almost two feet wide, they are built around a 4 inch diameter cylinder with rotating vanes around the cylinder.  The theory behind a cylindrical slide rule is that by wrapping the scales in a helical fashion around the cylinder the scale can be made considerably longer.  The longer the scale, the more accurate the computations. The principal difference between the two Thatcher models is that the 4013 has a bar across the front of the device to which is attached a magnifying glass that can be adjusted to "read" the answer to a computation.  This allowed the device to be very precise -- so much so, that it was the most accurate device available for many years.  And to get the most out of the accuracy, you really do need a magnifying glass to "read" it.  It turns out that the 4013, while more expensive than its brother 4012, had many fewer produced, and consequently, they are extremely hard to find in good condition -- and they are so very expensive.

Now, back to the story, I assumed it would be a 4012 and probably, like most, fairly deteriorated.  The response I got said it was a 4012 and after a few more back and forths, I concluded it was worth seeing.  It turned out, of all places in the world that it could be, it was about an hour away, in Springfield, MA.  I hopped in the car, went to the bank to get the required cash, and off I went to Springfield from Connecticut.

I arrived at a small house in an older section of town. I knocked at the door and this woman came and let me in.  She showed me to the table where she had on display, unbeknownst to me, two Thatchers.  One was a 4012, and... the other ---the other  was the Holy Grail -- a model 4013.  I tried to restrain myself from showing how elated I was.

The story took a very strange turn.  She was apologizing to me that she had me come all that way, but she had already sold the 4012 Thatcher that I had come to buy........ But, if I was interested, she had this other one almost the same over here.  I knew it, it was a bait and switch!

I looked it over, it was beautiful. It was well preserved, and it had all its parts. "I'll let you have this one for the same price" she said.  "I'll take it"

So, that's how I got the Thatcher and now it sits right next to the Curta in the display case in my living room. But that was not always the case.  I had not purchased the Curta at that time. I was still on the trail to find one.... and that is the next interesting adventure.